‘I would love to meet these $91/h accountants’: Tax profession slams trust tax report
BusinessWhile one tax lawyer said he is unsurprised that a “government-controlled” committee has recommended that the trust tax bills be passed, the NTAA said all concerns expressed by stakeholders have “fallen on deaf ears”.
The Senate Economics Legislation Committee released its report on the discretionary trust tax reform proposals after holding hearings over two days this month, and both the Greens and Labor recommended that the bills be passed through parliament.
The tax profession has reacted with disappointment at this recommendation but collectively said they were not surprised by it. They particularly highlighted that many of the concerns expressed by the tax profession, industry bodies, and other stakeholders on the Treasury Laws Amendment (Tax Reform No. 3) Bill 2026 and Income Tax Rates Amendment (Minimum Tax on Discretionary Trusts) Bill 2026 have been ignored.
‘Sham’ consultations, feedback ignored
Principal at Cartland Law Adrian Cartland said there was no surprise in the recommendation.
“A government-controlled committee has waived the bills through, ignoring almost all of the professional evidence, just as every consultation on this measure has been ignored,” Cartland told Accountants Daily.
“Those consultations have been a sham.”
However, Cartland said he was surprised by the committee’s statement that of the business trusts that are expected to require more significant advice as a result of the tax changes, between 70 per cent and 90 per cent will make an excluded election trust (EET) election and remain exempt from the minimum 30 per cent tax without restructuring.
“In my view, almost none of them should,” he said.
“A discretionary trustee must give real and genuine consideration to its beneficiaries every time it exercises its power. An EET election commits the trustee, years in advance, to fixed shares chosen for tax. STEP Australia told the committee this is an unlawful fetter on the trustee’s discretion unless the deed permits it. STEP is right. Tax does not displace the trustee’s fiduciary duty.”
Cartland also called Treasury’s impact analysis, which estimated that families and businesses would spend around $48 million every year to comply with the changes should it become law based on a price of advice of $91 per hour “extraordinary”.
“I would love to meet these $91-an-hour accountants,” he said.
“Surely, I’m paying far too much. Restructuring advice will cost most businesses $10,000 to $50,000 before stamp duty.”
National Tax & Accountants’ Association (NTAA) senior advocate Robyn Jacobson said the committee’s recommendation that the bills pass has come despite Treasury itself telling the inquiry that further technical amendments will be required. She also pointed out that there is less than four weeks to examine three schedules affecting more than 800,000 discretionary trusts, which “is not adequate scrutiny”.
“From the outset, the NTAA has said these measures should not proceed in their current form,” Jacobson told Accountants Daily.
“We have made that case at every stage, from Treasury’s consultation paper to the Senate committee, as have stakeholders across the profession and the business community in more than 250 submissions to the inquiry. Those concerns have fallen on deaf ears.”
Jacobson called for the start date to be deferred so any issues are fixed before the law is enacted rather than “patched” afterwards, stressing that practitioners will be operating with this regime for decades.
“The design problems are real,” she said.
“Because the offsets are non-refundable, an individual needs a taxable income of $229,320 before their average rate reaches 30 per cent. The cost falls on families with modest incomes and on vulnerable beneficiaries, while the highest earners pay nothing extra.
“The EET option freezes the family group as of 2028–29. It makes no allowance for grandchildren born later, incapacity, bankruptcy or family and domestic violence.”
In the report, Greens senator Nick McKim recommended that the bills should pass the parliament once the exemption for income to unauthorised charities and tax-exempt entities has been removed from the bill.
Jacobson expressed concern about this recommendation, arguing that “it should stay” and that the government included the exemption after the NTAA raised it in its submission.
“Many churches, schools and not-for-profit sporting and community associations rely on trust distributions to fund essential services to the community,” she said.
Huge decisions to be made in limited time
TaxBanter head of education and Accurium head of tax education Lee-Ann Hayes said that while broader trust tax reform would be welcome if it aimed to reduce complexity, many submissions raised concerns about how the changes would be delivered.
“I share those concerns,” she told Accountants Daily.
“The legislation is complex, and a good deal of important detail is either not yet known or has been left to legislative instruments and further legislation. That makes it hard for advisers and their clients to plan with confidence.
“Timing is my biggest worry. Accountants already have a great deal on their plates with the wider tax reform agenda, and advising clients on these changes means first taking the time to understand the impact of rules that are still being finalised. That time is already stretched, and clients are being asked to make significant decisions with limited information.”
Birchstone Legal Group associate director Tracey Dunn expressed disappointment that the committee has “accepted a minority view that opponents have an interest in seeing it abandoned” despite expert evidence showing the measure’s complexity, and the cost and impact on small businesses, primary producers, and vulnerable Australians.
“The 30 per cent minimum tax does not target the wealthy,” Dunn asserted to Accountants Daily.
“It targets small businesses, low- and middle-income earners and the vulnerable. The electable entity regime remains complex and designed to fail, and key elements of the rollover are still missing.
“The committee’s claim that fewer than 5 per cent of businesses will need significant advice is unsupported by evidence. Its estimate that 70 to 90 per cent of businesses will be unaffected because of the election and rollover is inconsistent with Treasury’s budget fact sheet. If correct, the measure won’t raise the revenue Treasury forecast – so why force taxpayers into costly advice?
“Tax reform is needed – but not in this form.”
Knowledge Shop tax director Michael Carruthers said that regardless of whether one agrees with the policy objectives that sit behind the bills or the way they have been drafted, if the bills are passed in their current form, clients impacted by this measure would need to make some critical decisions over the next couple of years on how they want to proceed.
“Decisions made in connection with the proposed amendments can have a long-term impact, and practitioners will need to work closely with clients impacted by these changes to help them understand the key options that are available to them, including the advantages and disadvantages of each, so that clients can make informed decisions,” he said.
“Each client scenario needs to be considered on its own merits. The approach that works for one client group might not work for another client.”
Want to see more stories from trusted news sources?Make Accountants Daily a preferred news source on Google.