Coalition senators refuse to support trust tax bill
BusinessThe Senate Economics Legislation Committee has handed down its report on the trust tax bills, with the Greens and Labor senators recommending passage of the bills while the opposition strongly opposed it.
Following the recent hearings into the Treasury Laws Amendment (Tax Reform No. 3) Bill 2026 and Income Tax Rates Amendment (Minimum Tax on Discretionary Trusts) Bill 2026, the committee released its report.
Coalition senators recommended that the Senate should not support passage of the first bill without removing the amendment to the income tax law to establish the minimum 30 per cent tax that would apply to the net income of discretionary trusts from 1 July 2028 (schedule 1).
Furthermore, the senators also called for the removal of schedule 3 from the bill, which would introduce an electable regime for certain discretionary trusts that are otherwise within the scope of the minimum trust tax. This regime would allow trustees to choose to make an election in the 2028–29 income year to become an excluded election trust (EET).
To qualify for the exemption, the trust must make a nomination specifying that it will make fixed distributions to pre-nominated beneficiaries.
If these recommendations are not actioned, the Coalition senators recommended that the start date be delayed by one year until 1 July 2029 as requested by business, accountants, and industry experts given the complexity of the proposals and the requirement for those impacted to seek advice to make informed decisions.
They also recommended that the legislation and its proposed amendments should be referred to a “fulsome” Senate inquiry, with a reporting date no earlier than 30 March 2027.
Censure of Treasurer
Should these recommendations not be actioned, the coalition senators went further and recommended that the Senate move a motion of censure of the Treasurer Jim Chalmers and the minister representing the Treasurer for several reasons.
These included “their persistent lack of transparency, refusal to provide accurate information to Senate estimates and this committee, failure for their officials to come prepared to hearings, and refusal to allow the Senate adequate time to consider this substantial legislation”.
Finally, the Coalition senators recommended that in the absence of an ongoing legislative inquiry, the Senate should support an ongoing economics reference committee inquiry to hear from “hundreds of thousands” of small businesses impacted, including in the agriculture and housing construction sector.
The senators argued that all options for small businesses under the trust tax reform proposals would result in “egregious” costs.
The pathways include:
- Maintaining current arrangements under the minimum 30 per cent tax
- Restructuring, which could result in high costs and uncertainty around stamp duty consequences
- Electing to enter the EET regime, which the senators said is “fundamentally flawed”, provides little flexibility, creates another layer of uncertainty and risk, and could require additional advice
- Beneficiaries become employees and take income as wages, which the senators said means small business owners would become employees of their own business and incur additional costs and less cash flow, and that often small businesses do not generate enough income for owners to even be paid a basic minimum wage.
Alongside this, the Coalition senators argued that the poor consultative and legislative process the government has applied to enact this bill is causing significant stress and uncertainty to small businesses, and noted that witnesses consistently bemoaned the lack of genuine consultation with small businesses.
“Unlike the government, the coalition has listened to the concerns of small businesses, including the hundreds who took time to prepare written submissions to this inquiry,” the senators said in the report.
Greens, Labor support bills
On the other hand, Greens senator and committee member Nick McKim backed the passage of the two bills in parliament once the exemption for income to unauthorised charities and tax-exempt entities has been removed from the bill.
“In an economy struggling to awaken productivity, having smart and creative people creating complex structures to avoid taxes is a complete waste of Australia's talent and productive potential,” McKim said in the report.
“Discretionary trusts are so popular in Australia because they offer a smorgasbord of flexible and adaptable tax minimisation opportunities, usually accessible only to those who have the necessary financial resources or expertise.
“This legislation curtails the flexibility of discretionary trusts and bucket companies so that they can no longer be deployed as conduits for shifting assets and income to their most tax-effective location. This aspect of the reform is undoubtedly positive.”
While McKim acknowledged that the reforms could increase costs for and “inconvenience” those small businesses that use trusts and bucket companies and will have to restructure, he argued that their use is not linked to better productivity or better commercial outcomes.
Labor senator for Victoria and committee chair Lisa Darmanin also said the committee recommends that the bills be passed.
While noting concerns around the lack of consultation on the bills and the broader tax reform package announced in this year’s federal budget, Darmanin said several rounds of consultation have been conducted.
The period of consultation for many of these rounds was around two weeks, although the Senate inquiry into the operation of the capital gains tax discount took place from November 2025 to March 2026.
“Consultation with business groups and key stakeholders has led to amendments reflected in the bills such as the election model (EETs), which allows existing trusts to be exempt from the minimum tax provided they keep to fixed distributions,” Darmanin said in the report.
“The EET builds on the existing commitment to provide rollover relief and reflects the Government's focus on finding ways to minimise the costs of restructuring for businesses that have organised their affairs under existing business structure rules.
“The committee believes that these arrangements strike the right balance between providing a way for existing trusts to adjust to these changes while ensuring a fairer rate of tax is paid in the future.”
Want to see more stories from trusted news sources?Make Accountants Daily a preferred news source on Google.