Accountant foresees ‘large-scale’ costs from ATO credit card ban
BusinessThe ATO’s credit card ban is a “wake-up call” as the government is witnessing the consequences of the RBA’s surcharge ban on government agencies, according to one accountant.
AMD Chartered Accountants director Miriam Bailey said the ATO’s recent announcement that it would cease accepting credit cards as a form of payment from taxpayers fulfilling their tax obligations has highlighted the lack of thought process behind the Reserve Bank of Australia’s moves to ban credit card surcharges.
While businesses have been told to absorb the costs of these surcharges, Bailey noted that the ATO Commissioner of Taxation Rob Heferen said in a statement that it is not tenable for the ATO to absorb the costs associated with accepting credit cards on an ongoing basis as it would result in less revenue being collected by the ATO.
Bailey said the ban by a government agency like the ATO has highlighted that the RBA’s surcharge ban on all designated debit, prepaid, and credit card systems could result in a “large-scale economic cost”.
“I do think that it’s a bit of a wake-up call for the government and I don’t see the policy being overturned anytime soon for anyone, including businesses,” she told Accountants Daily.
While the ATO initially said it would stop accepting credit cards from December this year, it said just a few days later that it will continue accepting credit card payments for tax obligations until 30 June 2027 following discussions with the government and the provision of transitional funding.
“We’re happy to have seen the ban overturned for a short period, but I am concerned for the long-term basis,” Bailey said.
“From the government point of view, the ATO carrying that surcharge is simply going to mean that they're going to need to find that revenue elsewhere. That is not good for the budget or for the Australian economy.”
Bailey underscored that the ban would have a significant negative impact on small businesses and their ability to pay the ATO as it will cause a significant cash flow crunch.
“I definitely think small businesses will be hit hard by this ban because a lot of the time, if their cash flow is tight, paying on a credit card gives them an extra 30 days to pay their business activity statement (BAS),” she said.
“As a result, they could still meet their tax obligations with the ATO on time.”
Bailey explained that businesses may now have to pay their suppliers using a credit card and use that cash to pay their tax to the ATO. However, she noted that not all suppliers accept credit card payments.
“If you’re paying for materials and other things, that option to be able to pay with a credit card is often not available to a business,” she said.
“Businesses have to find the money and perhaps think about liaising with a bank and setting up an overdraft facility. There are ways around it, but it sucks up extra time. We all know that anyone who runs a small business is poor on time.”
While noting that some businesses may increase their use of credit cards to make their tax payments to the ATO before the ban comes into effect to accrue more points, Bailey said she does not foresee businesses that never used credit cards suddenly using them before the ban.
“I can see the advantage around accumulating points, but I think the people who were relying on it before will continue to use it, but the ones who aren’t using it now won’t suddenly start using it,” she said.
Asked if government agencies like the ATO should be exempt from the RBA’s surcharge ban, Bailey said it is an option but warned that it would cause an uproar among businesses.
“If the government agencies are exempt, why should a small business have to carry this surcharge and have it significantly impacting their profit?” Bailey said.
“It would be inequality. It wouldn’t be a level playing field.”
Bailey also pointed out that many small businesses cannot afford to access services like cash flow forecasting from accountants, and the credit card offered an affordable alternative to managing cash flow.
“Cash flow forecasting is an option for clients to be able to show them when those dips are expected, so that clients can plan in advance,” Bailey said.
“But cash flow forecasting for the average small business is not a service that is sought out as it’s expensive. We do a lot of forecasting for our larger businesses.”
Want to see more stories from trusted news sources?Make Accountants Daily a preferred news source on Google.