The law of unintended consequences – 1 of 10 certainties now the minimum 32% tax on trusts is a done deal
TaxThe consultation is over, the minimum tax on trusts is effectively locked in, and the law of unintended consequences is about to take over. Amongst the 10 certainties as to what likely comes next are that ordinary taxpayers will disproportionately bear the greatest cost, advisers will be overwhelmed, and capital and talent will increasingly look offshore, writes Matthew Burgess.
The tax reform “consultation” process can officially be declared a stunningly spectacular success story.
Not a single responsible suggestion appears to have made it into the legislation.
This is the kind of consultation process professional politicians and Treasury power brokers fantasise about.
And all completed in record time (undoubtedly assisted by the fact that in at least one instance, legislation was introduced into Parliament before the consultation period closed; together with the innovative new strategy of leaving key aspects of legislation to be implemented by ministerial announcement as and when the said minister can be so bothered).
Huge industry resources have also been successfully diverted into the process; all at the cost of taxpayers who would have otherwise had materially better access to their advisers over the last few months.
The stage is now set for the rollout of ’record tax breaks for ordinary Australians’ in the May 2027 budget, followed shortly thereafter by the announcement of the next federal election.
Against this background, there are arguably 10 certainties for all taxpayers not otherwise on the payroll of BigGov.
1. Big government and professional politicians will continue to demand a greater share of revenue
The stated targets may change. The direction will not.
Anyone with any of the following assets should assume they will be a key part of the addressable market when the next round of changes are introduced (say, after the next federal election):
(a) an SMSF balance of any description (with the financial blackmail designed to force taxpayers into industry funds);
(b) a family home (ie the sale of a principal place of residence will become taxable; and perhaps even taxed on a yearly basis on any notional gain if the value increases, regardless of whether it is sold);
(c) any wealth at the date of death (ie death taxes to be rolled out to every person, not only those using a testamentary trust will).
2. Other than providing a short-term fix for the government’s spending addiction, the only winners are tax advisers
Professional advice costs attributable to the trust reforms alone have been estimated by CPA Australia at between $2 billion and $2.8 billion, before restructuring, implementation and state duty costs.
The estimate in all likelihood is materially below the actual investment that will be required.
There has possibly never been a better time to be a tax adviser, other than the minor technicality of finding one with sufficient bandwidth to assist.
3. Taxpayers with competent advisers and access to their workflows will actually be fine
The central political promise is that sophisticated structures will no longer provide sophisticated outcomes.
The likely practical position, based on the entire history of tax architecture, suggests anyone with access to competent advice will be no worse off.
Taxpayers who obtain early access to specialist advice will not be impacted by the rule changes at all.
4. Those most adversely affected by the reforms are those claimed to be protected
The minimum tax is presented as a fairness measure protecting ordinary taxpayers from income splitting.
As the law of unintended consequences explains, government interventions often produce the diametrically opposite outcomes of those intended.
At least in relation to the 30 per cent tax on trusts, and likely also the CGT and negative gearing changes, the burden will in fact be borne entirely by the very taxpayers the marketing blurbs claim to be protecting.
The irony of the outcome is bordering on comical, were it not so serious.
And the reality is that those same taxpayers who will carry the cost of the reforms are those least likely to understand the effect until it is too late to address the inequity.
5. No competent adviser will recommend an EET election
The further ’innovative’ creation of the excluded election trust (EET) regime is promoted as a solution likely to be adopted by circa 90 per cent of trusts.
The claim, apparently driven by academics who evidently have no actual understanding of why trusts exist (other than the unhinged narrative that “trusts are how the rich evade tax”), is so misguided that it would be at the risk of litigation in negligence if offered by a professional adviser.
More kindly, it is a stark reminder of the maxim that in theory there is no difference between theory and practice; although in practice there is.
History will show, no adviser will recommend an EET election be made, other than perhaps for trusts that are almost certain to have a material liquidity event within 24 months of the new rules commencing.
6. The ’greenmail’ demand for a list of every potential discretionary trust beneficiary is embarrassingly incoherent
The demand made as part of the Senate enquiry for a list of every potential beneficiary of every trust in Australia is likely proof that those driving the reform process have no understanding at any level about the issues they are seeking to solve for.
At a minimum, it demonstrates a complete conflation of trusts and companies.
It also, arguably naively, fails to consider that the current government unilaterally and without warning implemented rules hiding address details on ASIC company records due to (assumingly very valid) concerns about privacy, safety and cyber-attacks less than 12 months ago.
It may be the ’eat the rich’ strategy is not a winning mantra in relation to discretionary trusts.
7. Ideologically fixated legislation will continue to miss the commercial reality of trusts
No competent adviser (and as a generalisation, the overwhelming majority of Australian tax advisers are competent) has ever said:
“Let us establish a trust with tax evasion as its dominant purpose.”
When professional politicians and academics who have never assisted a business founder, investor or family group dominate the design process, policy tends to treat every trust as complete and irrefutable evidence of tax-related misconduct.
The reality is that trusts always have, and always will, offer material value to those who understand them across a myriad of criteria including intergenerational wealth management, asset protection, incapacity planning and the management of complex family circumstances.
To use (and mix) sporting principles; so long as Treasury continue to focus on the player, not the ball, they will completely miss where the puck is heading.
8. Attacking administrative missteps will increasingly be the mode of choice for the revenue
The greater risk for taxpayers and their advisers is not always the headline tax rate.
Rather, it is the interaction between extraordinarily complex rules and a revenue authority increasingly willing to treat benign administrative failures as substantive tax events.
There is a material difference between collecting tax on economic income and collecting tax because someone missed a step in a process no reasonable taxpayer could navigate without specialist advice.
The mistrust the rollout of this approach is creating should not be underestimated.
Particularly given the new extraordinarily complex taxation of trusts regime, which is built on a foundation of extraordinary complexity.
9. All of BigGov is coming for those not on the government’s payroll (and in reality, those who are also)
Anecdotally, and statistically, an immediate second-order consequence of the 2026 federal budget is an epic, negative reset in the property market.
State revenue authorities depend on stamp duty from property transactions to fund their spending addictions.
It may be that undertakings by state-based (would-be) elected representatives to provide stamp duty concessions for those suffering due to the (effectively) retrospective attack on trusts at a federal level are what those who are not professional politicians would refer to as ’bait and switch’ tactics.
That is, a promise prior to an election to act in a certain matter will be subject to change without notice on the basis that it was not actually meant to be interpreted as a promise that was binding.
10. Australia’s talent drain is on
Not only has the drain of talent from Australia started, but the 2026 budget reforms will also accelerate it on at least three levels.
First, the conduct of our professional politicians means that only a certain kind of person is interested in partaking and serving.
Like attracts like.
Individuals with out-of-control spending addictions tend to hang around with those of a similar mindset. This does not bode well for the calibre of person interested in participating in the political sphere.
Second, as flagged above, these are halcyon times for tax advisers.
And yet, the talent drain from the industry is real, has also started, and is likely to rival the unprecedented exodus from the financial planning industry when the rules imposed by the bureaucratic overlords became untenable for so many trusted advisers over the last decade.
Third, well outside the high-profile examples, every self-aware entrepreneur, business owner, employer, designer and investor considers their after-tax return.
After-tax returns are what seed the next wave, the next innovation, the next opportunity to create something bigger than themselves and perhaps make a difference to the wider community; or even leave a legacy.
As Kerry Packer so helpfully explained, back when consultation meant something closer to how it is defined in the dictionary, any Australian who doesn’t do so needs their head read.
When the after-tax return is crippled by an attack that, by any historical test, is completely out of step with Australia’s economic reality, and the taxation approach offered by so many amazing jurisdictions across the globe (that do not need to fund irresponsible public spending addictions), there is a blatantly obvious consequence. People, capital and ideas will find another home.
Matthew Burgess is the director of View Legal.
Want to see more stories from trusted news sources?Make Accountants Daily a preferred news source on Google.