‘ATO aims to always treat taxpayers fairly’: Tax Office responds to calls to restore ‘humanity’

Business

Following accounts by accountants about hurdles they have faced in dealing with the ATO, the Tax Office has said it always aims to keep taxpayers informed and help them understand their options.

20 November 2026 • By Malavika Santhebennur • 7 minutes read
Share this article on:

Accountants Daily recently reported the experiences of chartered accountant and owner of Gail Freeman & Co, Gail Freeman, who said her individual and taxpayer clients are currently “terrified of the ATO” and the inconsistent processes for fulfilling their tax obligations.

“I think the ATO has lost sight of the fact that they’re dealing with people. They’re inconsistent,” Freeman told Accountants Daily.

When asked how the ATO should treat individual and small business taxpayers as well as accountants, Freeman said she would like to see “humanity”.

In addition, AMD Chartered Accountants and Advisors’ director Miriam Bailey shared that she faced difficulties with a case where she applied for an ATO penalty remission for an individual taxpayer who is a low-income earner with significant mental health issues and acknowledged that they were late in fulfilling their tax obligations.

Following the publication of her story on Accountants Daily, the ATO reached out to Bailey about her client. Bailey told Accountants Daily that she was pleased the ATO contacted her and is hopeful that her application would have a positive outcome.

Tax Office says it can help taxpayers meet their obligations

Accountants Daily put questions forward to the ATO about how it treats taxpayers and the processes it applies to determine tax outcomes.

 
 

An ATO spokesperson told the brand that it “aims to always treat taxpayers fairly and reasonably”, and provide support and assistance, keep them informed, and help them understand their options, consistent with the ATO Charter.

The ATO Charter states that the Tax Office will treat taxpayers with courtesy, consideration, and respect, act with honesty and integrity, be impartial and act in good faith, treat taxpayers as being honest unless they have reason to think otherwise and give them an opportunity to explain, and work with whoever the taxpayer has chosen to represent them, such as a professional adviser.

“We understand people may need help in different ways, at different times,” the ATO Charter states.

“We know it may be harder for you to meet your obligations if you are experiencing vulnerability, difficult times or are impacted by crisis events. While we can't remove your obligations in most cases, there may be ways we can assist you to meet them.”

The charter states that the ATO will:

  • Listen to the taxpayer’s circumstances and take them into account where possible
  • Provide support during crisis events and difficult times
  • Provide assistance if the taxpayer requires help understanding or accessing services.

The ATO spokesperson also said the ATO recognises that illness, financial hardship, and other circumstances could impact a person’s ability to meet their tax and super obligations.

They said they would encourage taxpayers and their representatives to contact them as early as possible so the ATO can understand their circumstances and identify the most appropriate assistance.

This could include more time to pay, payment plans, remission, or connecting them with other support and assistance relevant to their circumstances, they said.

“We acknowledge feedback about consistency and transparency in relation to our support for taxpayers having difficulty meeting their obligations,” the ATO spokesperson said.

“We are committed to continuous improvement and are progressing changes to make it easier for taxpayers and tax professionals to understand when remission is likely to be granted and what information to provide and to ensure our decisions are supported by clear reasons.”

Balancing act of debt collection and supporting taxpayers

The ATO’s debt book is over $60 billion, and as such, it is balancing the need to collect outstanding tax obligations with supporting taxpayers experiencing difficult circumstances or other barriers to meet their obligations, the spokesperson pointed out.

“We also recognise the importance of taxpayers feeling heard and understood when they contact us, particularly when they are experiencing difficult personal circumstances,” the spokesperson said.

“Understanding those circumstances is an important part of providing appropriate support. Even where the tax outcome cannot change, we expect our interactions to be respectful and empathetic and to help taxpayers understand their options.

“Our ongoing work to strengthen the ATO’s vulnerability capability is focused on improving how we recognise and respond to people experiencing vulnerability, consistent with the commitments set out in our vulnerability framework.”

Why similar cases have different outcomes

Freeman also said she is serviced by a different person at the ATO every time we contact them.

Addressing this concern, the ATO said it administers the tax and super system at a large scale and receives more than 100,000 remission requests each year through its penalty and interest hub.

“Given the scale of our operations, taxpayers and their representatives are likely to interact with different staff,” the spokesperson said.

“We aim to support consistent decision-making through common processes and guidance, staff training and support, and quality assurance. These mechanisms help us monitor decision-making and identify opportunities to improve consistency.”

Furthermore, the spokesperson explained that remission decisions are based on the facts and circumstances of each request.

Staff consider the information given by the taxpayer or their representative alongside the information already available to the ATO, which could include their compliance history, they said.

“This means apparently similar cases may not result in the same outcome.”

Bailey highlighted that she has been seeing inconsistencies with the way taxpayers are treated even in seemingly identical circumstances, debts, and compliance history.

“We’re seeing this more and more where we don’t get equal treatment for different situations. The hoops that you need to jump through when you’re just trying to set up a payment arrangement is ridiculous,” she told Accountants Daily.

Accountants DailyWant to see more stories from trusted news sources?
Make Accountants Daily a preferred news source on Google.
Tags: