‘Are you trying to break this person?’: Accountant shares hurdles negotiating with ATO
BusinessAn accountant has lamented the lack of compassion shown by the ATO to a taxpayer with serious mental health issues in relation to requests for remission of penalties.
AMD Chartered Accountants and Advisors’ director Miriam Bailey has outlined a case where she applied for an ATO penalty remission for an individual taxpayer who is a low-income earner with significant mental health issues and acknowledged that they were late in fulfilling their tax obligations.
Bailey stressed that the taxpayer was not attempting to escape from paying the original debt and was indeed trying to fulfil their tax obligations and “do the right thing”.
“I’m looking at the ATO and thinking, ‘are you trying to break this person’?” Bailey told Accountants Daily.
“We’re not talking huge amounts of dollars. We’re talking about a genuine situation with medical practitioner’s evidence explaining why there was a lack of compliance with the tax obligations.
“We’re talking about someone who’s now back on top of things but the ATO is being so difficult with being able to negotiate.”
Collectable debt remains a major focus for the ATO as its debt book figure was expected to exceed the $115 billion figure from the previous figure, rising from $96.3 billion at the end of June 2023.
Commissioner Rob Heferen told The Tax Summit earlier this year that the ATO will use general interest charge (GIC) as a key tool to “restore greater rigour in the system and ensure more people are paying on time”.
While Bailey commended the ATO for showing compassion during COVID-19, she condemned it for the hard line it is currently taking on its debt collection activities.
“It’s like they’re going backwards and cracking down on everything after showing some compassion during COVID,” she said.
“There needs to be compassion. There needs to be a person on the other side of the phone who is making these decisions that isn’t just ticking off a checklist. They need to look at the evidence we present to them and make informed decisions.”
Bailey also said there are inconsistencies with the ATO’s communication and outcomes on director penalty notices (DPNs). She said the issuance of DPNs has been haphazard, as she has seen no DPN issued in cases where debts have existed for a prolonged period, but a client who was late on one business activity statement (BAS) and had no history of non-compliance is being issued with a DPN.
“We’re also finding it very difficult to negotiate with the ATO on payment plans. They ask for so much information,” she said.
“Sometimes you get a payment plan through really easily. Other times we have to provide large amounts of information around capacity to pay, which takes a long time to put together. After all that, the people on the other end of the phone don’t even seem to understand how to read the information.”
Bailey cited an instance where she prepared information on the income and expenses of a business to determine the take-home amount for the owner.
“The person on the other end said the business owner has those funds available to put towards the ATO debt,” she said.
“I asked them if they realised that those trust profits were equivalent to the family’s income for paying their mortgage and bills. I had to tell them that, no, they do not have all this money to pay directly to the ATO. They need to live on this money as this is their taxable income for the year.
“When I explained that, it was like a light bulb moment for the ATO officer who realised that this isn’t just spare money sitting in the bank.”
To further illustrate the inconsistencies in treatment of taxpayers, Bailey said she was designing a payment arrangement for a husband and wife with identical situations, debts, and compliance. While she had no issues arranging payment for the wife, it took a significant amount of correspondence with the ATO and time to arrange the payment for the husband.
“The client therefore had to pay me for my time in preparing this information and liaising with the ATO but the payment arrangement took five minutes for the wife. Where’s the sense in that? It was ridiculous,” Bailey said.
“We’re seeing this more and more where we don’t get equal treatment for different situations. The hoops that you need to jump through when you’re just trying to set up a payment arrangement is ridiculous.”
Bailey asked for a holistic approach by the ATO to recover its debts rather than an “authoritarian crackdown”.
“We are a nation of entrepreneurial spirit and small businesses, who give character to small towns and employ so many people. We don’t want to see all that closed down and replaced by big chains,” she said.
“Where is individuality going to disappear to if the ATO continues to make it harder and harder for taxpayers?”
Want to see more stories from trusted news sources?Make Accountants Daily a preferred news source on Google.