Accountant loses unfair dismissal claim, FWC rules ‘genuine redundancy’
BusinessThe FWC has tossed an accountant’s unfair dismissal application after finding that her firm had engaged in a genuine redundancy under the Fair Work Act.
In the case of Mrs Navlit Chand v Western Highway Investments Pty Ltd, Navlit Chand, who worked as an accountant, was dismissed on 14 July 2026 on the basis that her former employer, Western Highway Investments (WHI), said her position was redundant.
During this period, WHI had employed five accountants, each responsible for one of the business units within a group of entities of which Western Highway Investments is a part.
At the time of dismissal, Chand was responsible for the WHI business unit, while Western Highway Investments also engaged around 10 support staff (including administrative and accounts positions) and around six stock controllers.
Chand reported to senior accountant Humpries, who in turn reported to chief operating officer Marshall.
In about June 2026, Marshall conducted a review of the accountants, support staff, and stock control positions, and it was proposed that the accountants no longer report to Humpries, and instead report directly to Marshall, with Humpries supporting him as his “2IC”.
HR manager Roos said the changes were “driven by the ongoing decline in sales at Western Highway Investments Pty Ltd”. It was identified that there were areas of inefficiency within parts of the business which could have been improved.
It was considered that Humpries could absorb the WHI accountant duties in addition to her other duties, including accountancy for a separate brokerage business associated with WSI.
Two other roles within the support staff group were also identified as being redundant, as a result of which the company could improve efficiency, reduce duplication of responsibilities, and ensure the accounting functions could be effectively managed within the revamped structure of the organisation.
As a result, Chand’s employment was dismissed as the company said her role was redundant and there was no longer a role that exclusively carried out the accountancy duties, but instead it was absorbed with other duties Humpries undertakes as the senior accountant.
The commissioner said it was difficult for Chand to accept that the company reduced the number of accountants it requires by redistributing some accountancy functions to another role and creating a composite of those and other duties undertaken by Humpries.
Chand challenged the redundancy on the ground that her job appeared to still exist by pointing out that the organisational chart still showed a position labelled “accounts department – WAG” with five accountants each reporting to Marshall, one of which was simply described as “accountant – WHI”.
However, the commissioner dismissed this claim by Chand, stating that they were satisfied that the changes the respondent made to its structure were to its operational requirements to boost efficiency amid ongoing decline in sales.
“The applicant accepted at hearing that the commission should not ignore the evidence given for the Respondent in this matter, that its organisational structure is not simply as depicted in this chart, and that Ms Humphries is undertaking the duties associated with the “accountant – WHI” role together with her other duties,” the commissioner said.
Chand’s second ground for her unfair dismissal application was that the company had not given her sufficient opportunity to respond and only discussed possible redundancies in general terms on 1 July.
While Chand expected a one-on-one meeting, the next conversation was on 14 July when she was told her position was redundant. She also said the company’s initial response to her claim listed the clerk’s award as applying to her.
The commissioner declared that the company’s consultation process with Chand about the restructure and her redundancy “fell short” of what would usually be expected of an employer in these circumstances.
However, they said that very few modern awards cover the employment of accountants and most are award-free, and as such they were satisfied that the company was under no obligation to consult with Chand about redundancy in any modern award or enterprise agreement covering her employment.
Chand’s third ground for her unfair dismissal claim was that the company had failed to properly consider moving her into another job. She pointed to a stock controller role advertised around the time of her redundancy and said her experience was relevant to around 90 per cent of the role.
However, the commissioner accepted Roos’ oral evidence that the stock controller position became available a couple of days after Chand’s dismissal, and there was no such vacancy when the company was considering the restructure.
“On the evidence before the commission, I am not satisfied that it was reasonable in all the circumstances for the applicant (Chand) to be redeployed within the respondent’s (company) enterprise or the enterprise of an associated entity of the respondent,” Chand said.
“There was no accountancy role into which the applicant could have been reasonably redeployed. I consider it reasonable that Mr Roos considered such a role was the only option the applicant would be favourably disposed towards, he having been given this impression in November 2025.”
The company also invited Chand to discuss the role in August, but she was overseas at the time and did not take up the invite or contact the company when she returned to Australia, the commissioner said.
As such, Chand failed on all three grounds, and her dismissal was declared a case of genuine redundancy under the Fair Work Act; as such, she could not have been dismissed unfairly.
Want to see more stories from trusted news sources?Make Accountants Daily a preferred news source on Google.