CA ANZ WA member suspended for lodgement failures, fined $4.7k

Business

The body’s disciplinary tribunal has suspended a member’s membership for six months after the TPB found his entities’ tax debts had grown to $1.4 million after he had failed to lodge 85 BAS for his related company entities as a director.

20 November 2026 • By Malavika Santhebennur • 6 minutes read
Share this article on:

Stuart Alexander Third from Western Australia has lost his membership of Chartered Accountants Australia and New Zealand (CA ANZ) for a period of six months from the date of the body’s decision. The disciplinary tribunal also determined that Alexander must pay $4,743 for the full costs and expenses of the proceedings.

The decision came after the Tax Practitioners Board (TPB) had found that Alexander had breached the Code of Professional Conduct of the Tax Agent Services Act 2009 (TASA) (namely the requirement to comply with the tax laws in the conduct of personal affairs).

The TPB also found that Alexander ceased to satisfy the requirement for registration as a tax agent to be a fit and proper person.

Following an investigation, the TPB found that Alexander had failed to lodge three individual tax returns (ITRs) by their due dates. In addition, it found that he failed to lodge 31 ITRs and 85 BAS of his related company entities by their due dates as a director of those companies.

He allowed these entities to accumulate tax debts of around $1.4 million.

Alongside this, the TPB found that Alexander had failed to notify the TPB that a related company of which he was a director entered into external administration within 30 days of the event as required under the TASA.

The TPB noted that the CA ANZ Professional Conduct Committee (PCC) had made findings and taken action against Alexander for failure to give timely notification to CA ANZ of the appointment of a liquidator to two of his related companies, and making a false declaration in respect of those two circumstances in a CA ANZ membership renewal application.

 
 

Alexander’s registration ceased with the TPB in June 2025, which was after the relevant conduct but before the TPB completed its investigation. The TPB determined that the details of Alexander’s conduct would be published on a public register for five years.

The PCC initiated a complaint pursuant to the powers conferred by by-laws, and after investigating it, the PCC referred the member to the tribunal by way of notice of disciplinary action (NDA).

This alleged that Alexander, by reason of the TPB decision and the findings as described above, had been the subject of an adverse or unfavourable binding determination by a statutory authority or body or regulatory authority in relation to his professional or business conduct or competence in breach of the by-laws.

The PCC and Alexander entered into an agreement on the sanctions and request to dispense with procedures. In this agreement, the member admitted the offence alleged in the NDA and agreed to facts relating to the offence.

The disciplinary tribunal determined that the allegation made against Alexander was established because the member admitted the allegation, there was no evidence that Alexander challenged or requested a review of the TPB decision, and as such, remained binding on Alexander, and the tribunal was satisfied that the TPB’s findings concerned Alexander’s registration obligations as a tax agent and therefore were in relation to his professional conduct.

To decide the sanctions that should be imposed on Alexander, the guidelines for the imposition of sanctions set out in Regulation CR 8.12 were considered, including:

  • Seriousness of his conduct, whether the conduct has occurred before, and if so, the nature, extent, and frequency of the conduct
  • His responsibility and accountability for the conduct
  • Whether he has failed to comply with any undertaking or agreement to remedy the conduct
  • How he treated the PCC, disciplinary tribunal and appeals council during the course of the investigation and determination of the complaint and any disciplinary proceedings.

Alexander’s six-month suspension was agreed upon provided he has discharged all of his personal outstanding lodgement obligations in relation to his and his associated entities and has entered into, and adhered to, a payment arrangement with the ATO in relation to his and his associated entities’ outstanding taxation debt.

“Whether the failures were wilful or due to an extreme lack of care, the conduct and finding that he had ceased to be a fit and proper person to hold registration as a tax agent fell well short of the standard of professional conduct required by this tribunal and which the public is entitled to expect of a CA ANZ member – that they are a person with a high degree of competence and integrity,” the tribunal said.

“While acknowledging the Member’s progress of rectification as at the date of the agreement, the sanction appropriately reflects an element of deterrence to the Member, and other members of CA ANZ, from engaging in conduct of this type in future.”

Accountants DailyWant to see more stories from trusted news sources?
Make Accountants Daily a preferred news source on Google.
Tags: